Garrett Popcorn

4 East Madison St.
Chicago, IL 60602

With 10 shops around Chicago and another 17 around the world, Garrett Popcorn proudly markets itself as a tradition in the Windy City. The popcorn shops are typically walk-up shops only, selling nothing but gourmet popcorn in a few different varieties. An outsider would be baffled as to how a business making popcorn could grow to operate so many locations operating full time on prime real estate. That outsider is getting ready for a very pleasant surprise. This isn’t the popcorn you buy at a farmer’s market. It isn’t the popcorn from your kid’s bake sale. It deserves its superior reputation.There are five basic flavors on the menu, a plain version, a buttery version, a caramel version, a cheese version, and what is known as the “Chicago Mix” which is a combination of the cheese and caramel types hand-mixed together. The Chicago Mix should be your first introduction to this scrumptious popcorn; the caramel corn is crunchy and covered in a sweet but not sticky caramel glaze. The cheesey variety is light but packs plenty of savory flavor; it’s less like cheese power and more like cheese sauce. Together they are a fantastic combination of sweet and savory. It’s a great snack.

The caramel corn is also the basis for a few extra varieties. In fact, the already sweet and delicious caramel crisp is also accentuated with four varieties: One each with added almonds, pecans, cashews, and macadamia nuts. It becomes a sumptuous desert item with a serious crunch. The quality of the ingredients that go into this popcorn are the secret. These aren’t the most creative preparations of popcorn, nor are they the most powerful flavors, but where these guys really shine through are how delicious the old fashioned snack comes out. You can almost taste the quality as though it were an ingredient. That said, I do wish there were more flavors of popcorn, some other kind of cheese. Some kettle corn. More variety would only benefit an already quality brand.

The popcorn is made daily in the stores, and I would imagine most of it is consumed fresh the day it is made. The company does, however, sell the popcorn in many decorative tins for corporate events and weddings. In fact, you can customize the tin you order. It’s a pretty cool concept. I will suggest that you finish it off within a week of when it is made. All popcorn goes bad pretty quickly but with Garrett Popcorn it’s particularly apparent. It dries out and hardens all too quickly. Keep that in mind.

For all its other merits though, Garrett has to be my favorite Chicago snack food.


  • There are only a few basic varieties, but I would definitely say the Chicago Mix is absolutely the first and best for you to try.
  • Note that the popcorn is sold in numerous tins and other things, but also comes in small bags. There are plenty of ways to buy and give.
  • Eat the popcorn quickly after you buy. It goes bad quickly.

Garrett Popcorn Shops on Urbanspoon


3 thoughts on “Garrett Popcorn

  1. Thank you for your wonderful review! I’m glad that you enjoyed The Chicago Mix.

    You are right that Garrett Popcorn is made fresh throughout the day. We think it’s the best way to enjoy the high quality ingredients and care that we cook into each small batch.

    Thanks again for visiting and sharing your thoughts.

  2. Buyers beware!! When in Chicago we always made a stop at Garrett to bring home delicious popcorn. That’s what we did on Thursday evening. On Friday afternoon we opened our popcorn to find it completely stale! I contacted Garrett and they could not have cared less. They said their bags only keep popcorn fresh for a few hours. How ridiculous. It had to have been stale before it was sold to us. We can forgive stale popcorn from time to time however not indifference to their customers!

  3. Poor customer service! I ordered 2 gallons in the “Winter Wonderland” tin but sent the Wrigley Field tin. Informed CS of the mistake, but Tristan there was no mistake… that they ran out of that tin. I asked if they could send a different Holiday themed tin, but said they don’t send empty tins. No regard to notify me, care to fulfill my order properly, or try to make it right.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s