Mellow Mushroom (Columbus)

2170 Polaris Pkwy.
Columbus, OH 43240

Mellow Mushroom is not your typical restaurant chain. With 100 locations across 15 states, the franchise seems to have all the trappings of a corporate food factory. But this chain breaks the mold of the standard line. Founded in 1974 by college students, Mellow Mushroom maintains an air of nonconformity — every Mellow Mushroom is a sports bar specializing in pizza, but beyond that, every single location has a radically different menu catering to the local cuisine. I should note I’ve reviewed the Nashville, Tennessee location as well.


This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The Columbus location of Mellow Mushroom is a lively-looking bar just off I-70 in Polaris. It’s got a lot of the basic items common to all Mellow Mushroom locations, but it’s also got some local cuisine, some local micro-brews, and keeps the quirk alive.

  • Funky Q Chicken: Barbecued chicken, caramelized onions, Applewood smoked bacon and sauce smothered in a Mozzarella and Cheddar cheese blend. Altogether the various elements mix extremely well into one very tasty pizza.
  • Mighty Meaty: An enormous pie topped heavily with meat! Mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and smoked bacon.
  • Great White: About as close to the classic Neapolitan pizza. A mix of provolone, feta and ricotta cheeses topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, roasted and fresh tomatoes, and onions.
  • Garlic bread: feels pretty simple, with cheese-covered Italian loaf.
  • Holy Shiitake: Shiitake, button and portobello mushrooms, caramelized onions, mozzarella, and a garlic aioli swirl. Topped with chives and shaved parmesan and a bit of truffle oil. You’ve got to realllly like mushrooms for this one.
  • Bruschetta is a masterful work of basil, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and garlic atop crunchy toasted thin bread. Olive oil and balsamic vinegar bring the whole dish together perfectly.
  • Philly cheese steak: a delightfully simple take on the Pennsylvania original, and it really evokes a simple flavor instead of cramming it with too many vegetables or other things to make it overly complicated. It’s no health food, though, I guess.

Where this iteration of Mellow Mushroom really stands out, I feel, is in the concept. Each restaurant and franchise owner gets the opportunity to design their dining room as they see fit, and the local version forgoes the cramped, lunch-centric type of place for a very wide open sort of whimsical mushroom world. But it’s not as weird as it sounds. In fact, it’s got a bar loaded with local brews from Cincinnati, Columbus, Kentucky, and other neighboring locales. You could almost miss out on the whole mushroom concept, if you wanted, since there are plenty of TVs and probably room for a band to play. This place has a much livelier, sports bar feel.

Mellow Mushroom is going to be a place you’ll remember regardless, but coming here with a certain kind of dining experience in mind really has its benefits. Come with sports and drinks in mind, and bring your friends.


  • I would say this location is better thought of as primarily a bar than a pizza place, something different from the others I’ve seen.
  • There’s a patio for summertime dining, and since this area is so far from Columbus’ crowded downtown, it’s a very pleasant atmosphere.
  • This location doesn’t have as strong a unique food menu from others, but its drinks are outstanding.

Mellow Mushroom on Urbanspoon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s